What is the Best Workout for Fat Loss: Cardio or Weights?

a young woman trains for CrossFit athletics by weight lifting doing a deadlift exercise

Estimated read time:

3

minutes

Still running for fat loss? Here’s what you’re missing.

You’ve been hitting the treadmill every day, clocking mile after mile, but the scale won’t budge. Frustrated? You’re not alone. Many people believe cardio is the only way to burn fat — but is that really true?

What if we told you that lifting weights could actually be more effective for long-term fat loss?

Let’s break down the facts so you can stop wasting time and start training smarter.

The cardio vs. weightlifting debate: where did it start?

For years, cardio has been crowned the king of fat loss. It’s simple: move more, burn more calories. But weight training? That’s ONLY for building muscle, right?

Not exactly.

This myth comes from a surface-level view of fat loss — focusing only on calories burned during a workout. But fat loss is about more than just your time on the treadmill.

Weightlifting and fat loss — it works!

Here’s what most people don’t know about lifting weights:

  • More muscle = a higher resting metabolism
  • Your body burns more calories even when you’re resting
  • Weight training triggers EPOC (Excess Post-exercise Oxygen Consumption)
  • That means you keep burning calories for up to 24–48 hours post-workout
  • When dieting, your body can burn muscle for fuel
  • Strength training helps preserve it — which is critical for sustainable fat loss

Cardio’s role: it is still important, but it is not a magic fix.

Let’s be clear: cardio isn’t bad — it’s just not the whole picture.

Benefits of cardio include:

  • Improves heart and lung health
  • Increases daily calorie burn
  • Reduces stress and improves mood

But relying only on cardio can lead to:

  • Muscle loss
  • Plateaus in fat loss
  • Increased appetite (and overeating)

Combining strength training and cardio: the smartest approach.

The most effective fat loss routines combine both cardio and strength training.

Here’s how to structure your week:

💪 Strength Training: 3–4 days per week
🏃 Cardio: 2–3 days per week (mix steady-state and HIIT)
🛌 Rest & Recovery: 1–2 days per week

FAQ: Common Questions About Cardio vs. Weights

Q: Should I lift weights or do cardio first?
A: It depends on your goal. If fat loss is the focus, lift weights first to use your energy where it counts.

Q: Can I lose fat without cardio?
A: Yes — diet and strength training alone can support fat loss. Cardio adds benefits but isn’t required.

Q: How long before I see results with weights?
A: Most people notice changes in strength within 3–4 weeks, and visual changes in 6–8 weeks with consistency.

The bottom line: muscle is your fat-loss ally.

If you’re trying to burn fat and change your body shape, cardio alone won’t cut it. Lifting weights builds the foundation for lasting change — by increasing metabolism, preserving lean muscle, and improving body composition.

💡 Small changes lead to big results. Start with 2–3 days of strength training and build from there.

How a Physical Therapist can help

Working with a physical therapist isn’t just for injury rehab. PTs:

  • Assess your movement and strength so you can lift pain-free
  • Help prevent injury and improve form

A PT can make sure your training is effective, efficient, and safe — so you can get results without setbacks. 

Final takeaway

Fat loss isn’t about choosing between cardio and weights — it’s about using both, strategically.
But if you had to pick just one for long-term success? Strength training wins.

Want to train smarter, not harder? Start lifting — and if you’re unsure where to begin, a physical therapist can be your best guide.

two people using dumbbells during exercise

Start your physical therapy journey today.

As physical therapists, we know the importance of movement for overall health and well-being. From injury recovery to achieving optimal performance, our passion is to help every patient reach their goals and live an active, pain-free life.

Blog Posts You May Be Interested In

Regular movement improves cardiovascular health, builds muscular strength, enhances joint mobility, and supports mental well-being. Women of all sizes can enjoy running on the beach, no matter what their weight!
Health & Wellness
Your health journey isn’t defined by a number on the scale — it’s defined by how well you move, how strong you feel, and how consistently you care for your body.
Exercise, health and wellness, Movement, physical therapy
racially diverse friends high-five during a run in the city
Health & Wellness
Set your New Year fitness goals up for success. Learn how physical therapy can help you plan ahead, prevent injury, and stay on track all year long.
Exercise, Fitness, health and wellness, injury prevention, physical therapy
Walking outside for movement is powerful in the pursuit of good health.
Health & Wellness
Discover how purposeful movement can transform your physical and mental health. Learn four key ways to get moving and start feeling your best today.
Exercise, health and wellness, Movement, physical therapy

How can we help you today?

Quick Links: